I loved this post from Valerie Strauss at the Washington Post about seven misconceptions in the area of learning - some of them coming from the norms of traditional education and some of them are perpetuated even in some education 'reform' discussions:

  1. Basic facts come before deep learning

    The idea that students must get the 'boring' stuff or memorize factoids before they can think critically or do interesting work is off - students will achieve higher levels of mastery when these basics or facts are embedded in engaging, student centered learning.
  2. Rigorous education means a teacher talking

    When students collaborate, communicate and create they are able to work new knowledge into meaningful learning experiences and projects - that doesn't happen easily when a teacher is merely spouting information to them, it is better addressed by leveraging the awesome power of a teacher to construct a path for students to discover that new knowledge.
  3. Covering it means teaching it

    Isn't there an old saying that you learn best by doing?  Many teachers think because I have gone through the chapter of information, then my students have internalized it.  Maybe not - teachers can ensure that those bits of information aren't forgotten by doing an activity that reinforces the learning and is of course engaging.
  4. Teaching to student interests means dumbing it down

    A child's brain is an amazing machine....new learning building on what it already knows.  Educators wanting to connect with student interest should leverage what is already in their brains and relate it to the classroom teaching.  Even children in Kindergarten will recognize if someone is giving them something that is too easy and will become quickly disengaged.
  5. Acceleration means rigor

    One of the most positive aspects of the Common Core standards would be the focus on deeper learning - laying a stronger foundation for later learning by taking the time to really understand material.  Some educators, schools, districts or even national programs tout that they cover more material and provide an accelerated program - one is wise to be wary of this approach.  In the quest for speed and volume, you are likely giving up true mastery for the learners as that often takes time to develop.
  6. A quiet classroom means good learning

    "Controlled chaos" - many very effective educators refer to their classroom environments this way.  It's ironic that learning has been classically staged in a quiet, single focus type of setting.  Many times the noise and activity show direct evidence of engaged and passionate learning taking place.
  7. Traditional schooling prepares students for life

    Does that mean that every year people in the work world shut down everything and take standardized tests to show progress?  Real life preparation involves many of the concepts that are considered non-traditional by many educators:  creativity, self-management/direction, multi-tasking, communication, collaboration, critical thinking and evaluation, communication and collaboration skills.

 

Views: 144

Comment

You need to be a member of The Know New Ideas Community to add comments!

Join The Know New Ideas Community

Comment by Steve Nordmark on February 22, 2012 at 12:05pm

Thanks for sharing this Dawn.  It's important to think about how a learner can "own her education" - as it relates to her and her learning community.  These definitely reinforce that goal.

Comment by Kathy Frye, Ed.D. on February 21, 2012 at 7:10pm

This article spells out myths about education very clearly.  Education, in general, is very slow to change.  Our schools are based on a system that began in the late 1800s, and many schools have been unable to break through the traditions of a system that no longer serves the students of today.  There are, however, schools that are putting the learners and their needs first.  These schools are preparing their students for an ever changing global economy.  The use of technology is not foreign, but a natural part of every class, every day.  As educators, we owe it to the students that enter our schools each day to provide them with the tools to enable them to be successful in life after graduation.  I like the way Heidi Hayes Jacobs says it in Curriculum 21, "Our responsibility is to prepare the learners in our care for their world and their future." 

Copyright © 2013 Knovation, Inc. All Rights Reserved.    

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service